Do You Need After-the-Event Insurance When a Funder Is Paying for Your Claim?
Your funder wants ATE cover in place before it signs. Here's why, how loser-pays rules change the answer from London to Singapore, and how the premium cuts into what you recover.
The Short Answer: In Loser-Pays Courts, Usually Yes
If your claim is heard in a court or arbitral seat where the losing side pays the winner's legal costs, expect your funder to require after the event insurance. Treat it as a condition of the deal, not an add-on. The funder pays your lawyers and experts. The ATE policy pays the other side's costs if you lose. Those are separate risks, and most funders don't want to carry the second one on their own balance sheet.
Where each side bears its own costs, as in most US litigation, the answer flips. ATE is rarely needed there unless a fee-shifting statute, an offer-of-judgment rule or a contractual costs clause brings adverse costs back in.
So the real question for a general counsel or claimant firm isn't whether ATE is good value in the abstract. It's three narrower ones: how large is your adverse costs exposure in this forum, who is legally on the hook for it, and how much of your eventual recovery will the premium take? The sections below take each in turn.
Why Funders Insist on Adverse Costs Cover They Could Write Themselves
A funder could simply promise to pay any adverse costs order, and some do, particularly in Australian class actions. Most prefer to lay that risk off to an insurer, for four reasons.
- Direct liability for costs. In England and Wales, courts can order a non-party funder to pay adverse costs. The older Arkin approach limited that exposure to the amount the funder had invested, but the Court of Appeal in Chapelgate v Money confirmed the cap isn't a fixed rule. A funder without cover is exposed to costs it can't easily size.
- Capital efficiency. Money held back against a possible costs order earns nothing. An insurer's policy lets the funder put that money into more cases.
- Security for costs. Defendants routinely apply for security against funded claimants, and a well-drafted ATE policy is often the cheapest way to answer that application (more below).
- A second underwriter. An insurer willing to cover the case has, in effect, reviewed the merits. Funders take comfort from that, and so should you.
The practical upshot: ATE is usually built into the term sheet from day one. If a funder offers to waive it, ask how it plans to cover adverse costs and security. Then ask whether the cost reappears elsewhere, typically as a higher return multiple.
How Loser-Pays Rules Change the Answer by Jurisdiction
Adverse costs exposure depends on how the forum shifts costs and how much the winner can actually recover. The table gives a general picture. Rules change and procedural detail matters, so confirm the position with local counsel before you sign.
| Forum | Costs rule in general terms | Typical ATE relevance |
|---|---|---|
| England and Wales | Loser pays, assessed on a standard or indemnity basis. ATE premiums have generally not been recoverable from the opponent in most civil claims for some years | High. Funders almost always require it |
| Australia | Loser pays. Security for costs is common against funded claimants and class action representatives | High. Funder indemnities are often used instead of, or alongside, ATE |
| Singapore | Loser pays. Third-party funding is permitted for certain arbitration and court proceedings, with disclosure obligations | Moderate to high, especially in arbitration where tribunals may order security |
| Hong Kong, DIFC, ADGM | Loser pays in courts and commonly in arbitration | Moderate to high |
| Canada (most provinces) | Partial loser pays, usually below actual spend | Moderate |
| Germany, Netherlands | Loser pays, but recovery follows statutory or scale tariffs that are often well below actual spend | Lower and easier to quantify. Legal expenses insurance is often more relevant |
| India | Costs at the court's discretion, often modest in practice | Low in most court cases |
| United States | Each side generally bears its own costs | Low, except under fee-shifting statutes or contract clauses |
International arbitration needs its own analysis. Most major institutional rules let tribunals award costs, and tribunals increasingly expect funding to be disclosed and weigh it when security is requested. A claimant funded in an arbitration seated in London, Singapore or Hong Kong should assume it faces adverse costs risk, whatever its home country's rules.
Security for Costs: When an ATE Policy Can Stand In for Cash
A security for costs order makes you pay money into court, or provide a bank guarantee, before the case can continue. For a funded claimant, often a special-purpose vehicle or a company in insolvency, that can mean millions of dollars locked up for years.
Courts in England and Wales have accepted ATE policies as security, but only where the policy genuinely responds. Defendants will look for gaps that would let the insurer walk away. In practice the policy will usually need:
- An anti-avoidance endorsement that stops the insurer avoiding the policy for non-disclosure or misrepresentation, at least as against the defendant
- A limit of indemnity that matches or exceeds the defendant's estimated costs at each stage
- An insurer whose financial strength the court accepts
- Ideally, a deed of indemnity or direct right letting the defendant claim against the insurer
Australian and Singaporean courts and tribunals tend to look at substance over form, although what they accept as adequate varies. Brief your broker on likely security applications before the policy is drafted. Fixing the wording after a hearing is listed costs time and usually premium.
Upfront, Deferred and Deferred-Contingent Premiums Compared
The ATE premium is usually quoted as a percentage of the limit of indemnity, and how it's structured matters as much as the rate. The ranges below are typical 2026 market ranges for commercial claims. They vary widely with case strength, duration, forum and contract terms, so get firm quotes through a specialist broker.
| Structure | When it's paid | Indicative premium (% of limit) | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront | At inception, win or lose | Roughly 10% to 25% | Strong cases where the funder or claimant has spare cash and wants the lowest headline rate |
| Deferred | At conclusion, win or lose | Roughly 20% to 35% | Uncommon in funded cases because the claimant still pays if it loses |
| Deferred, contingent on success | Only out of recoveries, only if you win | Roughly 25% to 50%, often staged | Most funded claims. The claimant pays nothing if the case fails |
Staging is common. A policy might charge a lower percentage if the case settles before disclosure, then step up at exchange of witness evidence and again at trial. Read the trigger points closely. A step that applies when the trial date is fixed rather than when trial starts can add hundreds of thousands of dollars to a case that settles at the courtroom door.
Where the Premium Sits in the Waterfall: A Worked Example
The waterfall is the agreed order in which recoveries are paid out. The insurer's deferred premium usually ranks first, or level with the funder's return, ahead of anything paid to the claimant. That's why premium structure matters to you even if you never write a check for it.
Hypothetical example. Say a manufacturer brings a $20 million contract claim in London. The funder commits a $4 million budget. The defendant's costs are estimated at $3 million, so the ATE limit is $3 million. The funder's return is its deployed capital back plus twice that capital. The case settles for $15 million after $2.5 million has been deployed.
Option A: deferred-contingent premium at 35%. The premium is $1.05 million. The waterfall pays the insurer $1.05 million and the funder $7.5 million ($2.5 million capital plus $5 million return), leaving the claimant $6.45 million.
Option B: upfront premium at 15%, paid by the funder. The premium is $450,000, but it counts as deployed capital, so deployed capital rises to $2.95 million. The funder takes $8.85 million ($2.95 million plus $5.9 million), and the claimant gets $6.15 million.
The lower headline rate costs the claimant $300,000 more, because the funder earns its multiple on the premium. If the case had lost, Option A costs the claimant nothing in premium, while under Option B the funder's $450,000 is written off. That's one reason funders favor contingent structures. Ask whether the premium counts as deployed capital, and model both options at early settlement, late settlement and trial.
Red Flags in the Policy and the Priorities Deed
Most ATE disputes come from policy wording and how it interacts with the funding agreement, not from the price. Watch for these:
- No anti-avoidance endorsement, or one that only partly protects you. Without it, the policy may fail exactly when you need it.
- Insurer consent rights over settlement that conflict with the funder's own rights, so two parties can each block a deal.
- Limits that don't step up as the defendant's costs budget grows, leaving you uninsured for later stages.
- Exclusions for costs incurred before inception or for indemnity-basis costs, which can leave a large share of a real costs order uncovered.
- A priorities deed that lets premium and funder return swallow the recovery at plausible settlement values, so you win and receive almost nothing. Ask for a minimum claimant share or a cap on combined deductions.
- Premium taxes that apply in some jurisdictions and aren't shown in the quoted rate.
Have independent counsel, not the funder's lawyers, review the policy and the priorities deed together. Rules on the enforceability of funding agreements are also unsettled in places, including England and Wales after the PACCAR decision, where reform has been under discussion. Get advice that reflects the position when you sign.
A Decision Rule for Claimants and In-House Teams
Put ATE in place when three conditions hold: the forum shifts costs, the defendant's likely recoverable costs are large relative to what you expect to recover, and you or your claim vehicle can't comfortably meet a costs order or a security application from your own resources. In England and Wales, Australia, Singapore and most arbitral seats that use loser-pays rules, a funded commercial claim will usually meet all three.
Before you sign the term sheet:
- Get litigation counsel to estimate the defendant's recoverable costs stage by stage.
- Get at least two ATE quotes through a specialist broker, covering both upfront and deferred-contingent structures.
- Model the full waterfall at three outcomes: early settlement, settlement close to trial, and judgment.
- Confirm the policy wording will satisfy a security for costs application in your forum.
- Have independent counsel review the policy, funding agreement and priorities deed together.
If modeled net recovery at a realistic early settlement falls below roughly a third of the gross figure, go back to the funder and the insurer and renegotiate before you commit.
Questions buyers ask
Can I recover the ATE insurance premium from the losing defendant?
It depends on the forum. In England and Wales, ATE premiums have generally not been recoverable from the opponent in most civil claims, with limited exceptions. Other jurisdictions and arbitral tribunals take different approaches, so ask local counsel and assume you'll bear the premium unless told otherwise.
Does the funder or the claimant pay the premium?
With a deferred-contingent premium, it comes out of recoveries, so in practice the claimant bears it through the waterfall. With an upfront premium, the funder often pays it and treats it as deployed capital, which can increase its return. Check which applies before comparing quotes.
How is the ATE limit of indemnity set?
It's usually based on a stage-by-stage estimate of the defendant's recoverable costs, sometimes with a margin added. Many policies let the limit step up as the case progresses. Too low a limit can fail a security for costs application or leave you uninsured for part of a costs order.
Will an ATE policy satisfy a security for costs order?
It often can, if the wording protects the defendant. That usually means an anti-avoidance endorsement, an adequate limit and a financially strong insurer. Courts look at whether the policy will actually pay, so get the wording reviewed before any security hearing.
What happens to the premium if we lose?
Under a deferred-contingent structure, no premium is payable and the insurer pays adverse costs up to the limit, subject to the policy terms. Under an upfront structure, the premium has already been paid and isn't returned. Some policies address partial premium if the case is withdrawn, so check the wording.
Do we need ATE for a funded claim in the United States?
Usually not, because each side generally bears its own costs. Exceptions include fee-shifting statutes, contractual costs clauses and offer-of-judgment rules, along with international arbitrations seated elsewhere. In those cases, ask a broker whether targeted adverse costs cover makes sense.
Written by the Counsel Ops HQ editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.